Messages in this thread |  | | Date | Thu, 7 Sep 2000 08:49:53 -0600 (MDT) | From | Chris Ricker <> | Subject | Re: Availability of kdb |
| |
On Wed, 6 Sep 2000, Jeff V. Merkey wrote:
> I have no axe to grind, but I do have a different view. I'm the 1 in 30 > million men born with an extra Y chromosone (a double YY), so you are > pertially right there. DOuble YY males have a different brain structure > -- the lymbic system in my brain is so electrically active, it qualifies > as a third brain. Normal humans have two brains, left and right. Like > most double YY's I have three, left, right, lymbic. Fortunately for me, > my frontal lobes are normal and do not exhibit the wiring problems that > afflict 60% of double YY's, such as an uncontrollable urge to take an > axe and chop someone to pieces because they pissed me off.
<putting on my human geneticist hat>
Not that any of this has anything to do with Linux kernel development, but you really should do a bit more background reading on 47,XYY. Incidence is much, much higher than you claim. Frequency estimates vary slightly with the study, of course, but it's usually somewhere around 1 in 1000 live male births (1 in 843 reported in Birth Defects 26:209-223, for example, and similar results in Prenatal Diagnosis 17:363-368. The *lowest* frequency I've ever seen reported was ~ 1/1250).
Similarly, no scientific study I've ever seen has substantiated any of that nonsense about "lymbic wiring" or three brains. [1] There's a very small correlation between 47,XYY and: tallness, slightly reduced IQ, hyperactivity, ADD, and learning disabilities. AFAIK, there's no demonstrated physiological difference between 46,XY males (ie, "normal") and 47,XYY; average testosterone levels are the same in both, for example (AACE report, 1998). If you actually know of scientific studies substantiating the above claim of a physiological difference in the brain or any other physiological differences, I'd really appreciate references. Ditto for the list of individuals you claim had 47,XYY -- the only "famous" person I know of with any connection to the condition was Richard Speck, who falsely claimed to be 47,XYY in an attempt to get leniency for his murders. I'm curious about your references because it's a condition which is quite common, but which is very rarely diagnosed precisely because it usually has no effect....
Sorry about responding to this on linux-kernel instead of privately, but 47,XYY is a condition for which most popular "knowledge" is both wrong, and quite persistent in its popularity and acceptance; furthermore, this incorrect "knowledge" is often detrimental to those with the condition (ie, Psychological Bulletin 78:209-233). Historically, it was popularly thought that 47,XYY was a condition leading to hyperaggression, criminal behavior, etc., and so those with 47,XYY were often treated accordingly. The scientific reality is far more boring; most males with 47,XYY -- like most males with 46,XY -- are as normal as males ever are, and should be treated accordingly ;-).
later, chris
[1] I suspect you're conflating two very different conditions, Klinefelter syndrome (47,XXY) and 47,XYY. Some studies (ie, J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 66:628-32) have demonstrated neurological differences for subjects with Klinefelter syndrome, but they have simultaneously demonstrated that neurological structures in 47,XYY subjects are no different than in age-matched 46,XY controls.
-- Chris Ricker kaboom@gatech.edu chris.ricker@genetics.utah.edu
- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in the body of a message to majordomo@vger.kernel.org Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/
|  |