Messages in this thread | | | Date | Wed, 3 Mar 1999 14:10:58 -0500 | From | "Daniel J. Frasnelli" <> | Subject | Re: [patch] PIII/Katmai & FXSAVE support, disable serial-#, 2.2.2 |
| |
> Not only that, but I've heard from the naysayers that the concept of > having ANY unique ID in your computer is bad. The first thing I thought of Well, I think that may be taking it to an extreme.. just my opinion. > was MAC addresses. All those cable modem/ADSL users already have a method > of identifying themselves given the right software (no, not arp). Yes, a MAC address does provide a semi-stable means of identifying a machine (I'll not digress into 101 ways to forge this). We use this method all the time when tracking an IP "bandit" on our network. Given a MAC, I can tell you with reasonable accuracy the NIC chipset manufacturer, workstation vendor, and often the identification of the chipset itself. This fact is not under dispute on the list as far as I know. The difference is in the details with the P3 psn. From what I understand (and this is limited, forgive me for inaccuracies here), the P3 psn is being presented as a means of providing web content restriction based on processor type. This may not be apparent right now, but may become further down the road. If the developer of your web browser codes something to pass the psn of your machine to a website upon connection (this is trivial to implement), an unethical webmaster may then be able to say "If you use the Pentium III or IV or Merced, etc. you can view content presented on this page. Otherwise, I send you to /dev/null". I research things such as communication/information theory on the side, and it is plain that the P3 psn can also be used as means of auditing the web sites visited, e-commerce transactions handled, etc. of a particular computer with a dialup account (and thus, an exact person or group of people). This is no small threat in a time where information warfare and intelligence operations are commonplace in both government and private sectors. Can you imagine the power such data would give a marketing firm when selecting target audience? "So Mr. Smith, I see you purchased a Widgetmaster 1000 in January... how would you like a special upgrade to the 2000 model?" At any rate, the rant is debunked in the end by the fact that anyone motivated to find information about you can do so through hundreds if not thousands of sources. The psn is yet another pebble in the mountain of an information warfare arsenaul. > Also, don't BIOSs carry ID stamps, too? Perhaps (I'm an Alpha guy, myself), but as another person pointed out, you are not likely to be passing this information over the network to a third party.
Regards, Daniel --
- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in the body of a message to majordomo@vger.rutgers.edu Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/
| |