Messages in this thread | | | Date | Tue, 14 Apr 2009 14:27:24 -0700 | From | "H. Peter Anvin" <> | Subject | Re: [PATCH] x86/pci: make pci_mem_start to be aligned only |
| |
Linus Torvalds wrote: > The reason? We've definitely seen ACPI code or integrated graphics stuff > that steals a lot of memory at the end, which means that end-of-RAM might > be not at 2GB, but at 2GB-16MB-1MB, for example (1MB of "ACPI data", and > 16MB of "stolen video ram").
This is pretty much standard these days. It's hard to implement ACPI without doing so. Throw in the SMI T-seg for even more fun.
> Now, the BIOS _hopefully_ marks those areas clearly reserved, and as a > result we don't end up allocating PCI data in there, but the gap was there > literally to make sure we always leave that gap, very much on purpose.
It would be nice if we would mark that memory reserved ourselves.
> thing, so that if the gap is large, then we'll certainly get to 32MB too, > but I think your patch matters the most exactly when the gap is small. > Maybe we could just raise the initial minimum rounding from 1MB to 32MB?
Since we're talking about address space, not actual memory, it seems rather hard to end up in a situation where either one of these is not true:
- we will have real hardware demand for a large alignment datum. - we will have so much address space available that it doesn't matter.
The latter case would be e.g. a machine with a today-anemic handful of megabytes of RAM.
-hpa[1]
[1] who remembers running a Linux server on a 0.59 bogomips i386/16 with 3 MB of half-speed memory...
| |