[lkml]   [2006]   [Dec]   [7]   [last100]   RSS Feed
Views: [wrap][no wrap]   [headers]  [forward] 
Messages in this thread
SubjectRe: [PATCH v2] libata: Simulate REPORT LUNS for ATAPI devices
James Bottomley wrote:
> On Mon, 2006-12-04 at 15:32 -0800, Darrick J. Wong wrote:
>> The Quantum GoVault SATAPI removable disk device returns ATA_ERR in
>> response to a REPORT LUNS packet. If this happens to an ATAPI device
>> that is attached to a SAS controller (this is the case with sas_ata),
>> the device does not load because SCSI won't touch a "SCSI device"
>> that won't report its LUNs. Since most ATAPI devices don't support
>> multiple LUNs anyway, we might as well fake a response like we do for
>> ATA devices.
> Actually, there may be a standards conflict here. SPC says that all
> devices reporting compliance with this standard (as the inquiry data for
> this device claims) shall support REPORT LUNS. On the other hand, MMC
> doesn't list REPORT LUNS in its table of mandatory commands.

MMC-5 rev 4 section 7.1:
"Some commands that may be implemented by MM drives are
not described in this standard, but are found in other
SCSI standards. For a complete list of these commands
refer to [SPC-3]."

Hmm, "may be implemented" yet REPORT LUNS is mandatory
in SPC-3 (and SPC-3 is a normative reference for MMC-5).
I guess there is wriggle room there.
In practice, MMC diverges from SPC a lot more than other
SCSI device type command sets (e.g. SBC and SSC).

> I'm starting to think that even if they report a SCSI compliance level
> of 3 or greater, we still shouldn't send REPORT LUNS to devices that
> return MMC type unless we have a white list override.

There is also SAT compliance. For the ATA command set (i.e.
disks) sat-r09 lists REPORT LUNS and refers to SPC-3. For
ATAPI sat-r09 is far less clear. It does recommend, for
example, that the ATA Information VPD pages is implemented
in the SATL for ATAPI devices.

Doug Gilbert
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to
More majordomo info at
Please read the FAQ at

 \ /
  Last update: 2006-12-07 20:17    [from the cache]
©2003-2014 Jasper Spaans. hosted at Digital Ocean