Messages in this thread | | | Date | Wed, 08 Mar 2000 00:55:05 +0100 | From | Jorge Nerin <> | Subject | ping -s 61992 vs ping -s 61993 in 2.3.48 |
| |
Problem: ping with a size greater than 61992 (+8 from pìng) doesn't reply from 2.3.48.
One machine: name head : Linux head.redvip.net 2.2.11 #1 Tue Dec 14 05:55:15 CET 1999 i486 unknown eth0: 3c509
The other: name quartz : Linux quartz.redvip.net 2.3.48 #9 SMP lun feb 28 01:00:27 CET 2000 i586 unknown eth0: ne2k-pci (Realtek 8029)
head console:
[root@head /root]# ping -s 61992 quartz -c 1 PING quartz.redvip.net (192.168.0.3): 61992 data bytes 62000 bytes from 192.168.0.3: icmp_seq=0 ttl=255 time=166.5 ms
--- quartz.redvip.net ping statistics --- 1 packets transmitted, 1 packets received, 0% packet loss round-trip min/avg/max = 166.5/166.5/166.5 ms [root@head /root]# ping -s 61993 quartz -c 1 PING quartz.redvip.net (192.168.0.3): 61993 data bytes
--- quartz.redvip.net ping statistics --- 1 packets transmitted, 0 packets received, 100% packet loss [root@head /root]#
And a tcpdump from quartz:
short:
00:31:46.414304 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1320@60680) 00:31:46.416247 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@59200+) 00:31:46.490558 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: icmp: echo request (frag 4572:1480@0+) 00:31:46.492921 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1320@60680) 00:31:46.493181 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@59200+) 00:31:46.543032 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: icmp: echo reply (frag 3175:1480@0+)
00:31:50.542692 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1321@60680) 00:31:50.544529 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@59200+) 00:31:50.618560 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: icmp: echo request (frag 4584:1480@0+)
full:
00:31:46.414304 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1320@60680) 00:31:46.416247 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@59200+) 00:31:46.418145 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@57720+) 00:31:46.420121 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@56240+) 00:31:46.421925 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@54760+) 00:31:46.423961 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@53280+) 00:31:46.425820 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@51800+) 00:31:46.427706 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@50320+) 00:31:46.429483 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@48840+) 00:31:46.431380 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@47360+) 00:31:46.433137 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@45880+) 00:31:46.435095 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@44400+) 00:31:46.436865 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@42920+) 00:31:46.438737 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@41440+) 00:31:46.440577 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@39960+) 00:31:46.442274 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@38480+) 00:31:46.444257 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@37000+) 00:31:46.445963 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@35520+) 00:31:46.447864 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@34040+) 00:31:46.449669 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@32560+) 00:31:46.451549 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@31080+) 00:31:46.453417 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@29600+) 00:31:46.455259 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@28120+) 00:31:46.457084 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@26640+) 00:31:46.458920 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@25160+) 00:31:46.460816 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@23680+) 00:31:46.462694 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@22200+) 00:31:46.464551 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@20720+) 00:31:46.466398 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@19240+) 00:31:46.468189 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@17760+) 00:31:46.470081 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@16280+) 00:31:46.471936 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@14800+) 00:31:46.473996 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@13320+) 00:31:46.475828 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@11840+) 00:31:46.477578 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@10360+) 00:31:46.479457 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@8880+) 00:31:46.481267 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@7400+) 00:31:46.483150 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@5920+) 00:31:46.485024 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@4440+) 00:31:46.486854 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@2960+) 00:31:46.488698 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4572:1480@1480+) 00:31:46.490558 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: icmp: echo request (frag 4572:1480@0+) 00:31:46.492921 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1320@60680) 00:31:46.493181 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@59200+) 00:31:46.494294 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@57720+) 00:31:46.495575 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@56240+) 00:31:46.496809 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@54760+) 00:31:46.498056 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@53280+) 00:31:46.499303 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@51800+) 00:31:46.500552 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@50320+) 00:31:46.501794 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@48840+) 00:31:46.503048 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@47360+) 00:31:46.504310 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@45880+) 00:31:46.505560 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@44400+) 00:31:46.506799 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@42920+) 00:31:46.508049 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@41440+) 00:31:46.509288 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@39960+) 00:31:46.510540 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@38480+) 00:31:46.511781 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@37000+) 00:31:46.513034 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@35520+) 00:31:46.514288 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@34040+) 00:31:46.515532 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@32560+) 00:31:46.516784 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@31080+) 00:31:46.518025 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@29600+) 00:31:46.519279 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@28120+) 00:31:46.520520 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@26640+) 00:31:46.521775 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@25160+) 00:31:46.523014 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@23680+) 00:31:46.524275 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@22200+) 00:31:46.525513 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@20720+) 00:31:46.526769 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@19240+) 00:31:46.528008 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@17760+) 00:31:46.529256 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@16280+) 00:31:46.530502 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@14800+) 00:31:46.531754 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@13320+) 00:31:46.532998 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@11840+) 00:31:46.534260 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@10360+) 00:31:46.535512 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@8880+) 00:31:46.536782 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@7400+) 00:31:46.538025 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@5920+) 00:31:46.539273 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@4440+) 00:31:46.540525 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@2960+) 00:31:46.541775 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: (frag 3175:1480@1480+) 00:31:46.543032 quartz.redvip.net > head.redvip.net: icmp: echo reply (frag 3175:1480@0+)
00:31:50.542692 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1321@60680) 00:31:50.544529 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@59200+) 00:31:50.546456 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@57720+) 00:31:50.548383 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@56240+) 00:31:50.550118 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@54760+) 00:31:50.552176 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@53280+) 00:31:50.553926 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@51800+) 00:31:50.555836 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@50320+) 00:31:50.557613 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@48840+) 00:31:50.559473 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@47360+) 00:31:50.561308 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@45880+) 00:31:50.563138 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@44400+) 00:31:50.564983 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@42920+) 00:31:50.566863 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@41440+) 00:31:50.568649 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@39960+) 00:31:50.570462 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@38480+) 00:31:50.572333 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@37000+) 00:31:50.574182 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@35520+) 00:31:50.576022 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@34040+) 00:31:50.577870 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@32560+) 00:31:50.579719 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@31080+) 00:31:50.581574 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@29600+) 00:31:50.583425 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@28120+) 00:31:50.585269 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@26640+) 00:31:50.587067 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@25160+) 00:31:50.588921 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@23680+) 00:31:50.590734 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@22200+) 00:31:50.592617 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@20720+) 00:31:50.594471 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@19240+) 00:31:50.596381 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@17760+) 00:31:50.598188 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@16280+) 00:31:50.600043 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@14800+) 00:31:50.601888 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@13320+) 00:31:50.603733 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@11840+) 00:31:50.605571 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@10360+) 00:31:50.607416 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@8880+) 00:31:50.609211 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@7400+) 00:31:50.611017 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@5920+) 00:31:50.612955 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@4440+) 00:31:50.614809 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@2960+) 00:31:50.616716 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: (frag 4584:1480@1480+) 00:31:50.618560 head.redvip.net > quartz.redvip.net: icmp: echo request (frag 4584:1480@0+)
As one can see the packets came and get replied if their total size is under 62001, if it's greater it's ignored, it doesn't ever show up in tcpdump.
And BTW in the other direction works ok.
[root@quartz ~]# ping -s 61993 quartz -c 1 PING quartz.redvip.net (192.168.0.3) from 192.168.0.3 : 61993 data bytes 62001 bytes from 192.168.0.3: icmp_seq=0 ttl=255 time=19.1 ms
--- quartz.redvip.net ping statistics --- 1 packets transmitted, 1 packets received, 0% packet loss round-trip min/avg/max = 19.1/19.1/19.1 ms [root@quartz ~]#
-- Jorge Nerin <jnerin@svalero.es> <comandante@zaralinux.com>
- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in the body of a message to majordomo@vger.rutgers.edu Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/
| |